• On TV.com: THE GIRLS NEXT DOOR photos
June 20, 2008 4:13 PM PDT

Rainwater harvesting advocates bring filter tech to the U.S.

Posted by Hanna Sistek
  • Font size
  • Print

SPICEWOOD SPRINGS, Texas--When Joe Wheeler built his new house here in 2001, he was told that it would cost $10,000 to drill a well, and that he wouldn't be able to drink or bathe in the water. Undaunted, he turned to the old-fashioned idea of rainwater collection to solve his water problem.

Wheeler talked to people who had experience with rainwater collection, and eventually installed what was available on the market at that time, so-called first-flush technology. The first-flush system he had installed sent the first, dirty batch of water from the roof into a diverter tube, and collected the rest in a tank. But he soon started questioning the efficiency.

"I don't think it's a valid idea to take 10 percent of the water off your roof and then assume that the rest of the water is fine. Just think about how long it takes to clean up your windscreen from whatever the birds leave on it," Wheeler continued.

Wheeler browsed around on the Internet and found WISY, a German rainwater filter manufacturer. Apart from buying a set himself, he became the company's first U.S. distributor.

How the WISY system works.

(Credit: Rainfilters of Texas)

How WISY works
Under the WISY system, which Wheeler distributes under the name Rainfilters of Texas, the gross filter first gets rid of the initial batch of water and all larger particles in it.

The first of the four WISY filters removes the larger particles.

(Credit: Hanna Sistek)

Then, the water flows to a calming inlet in the storage tank. In the third step, water is pumped back from the tank through a floating suction filter, avoiding sucking up the bottom tank water where bacteria accumulates. Last but not least, a surface-skimming tube on the tank gets rid of particles floating on top.

WISY system's floating suction filters

(Credit: Hanna Sistek)

Once pumped up from the storage tank, Wheeler's water runs through two filters (the blue ones in the photo) and finally the last germs are eliminated with UV light (the metallic cylinder in the photo). This makes the water safe enough to drink.

WISY system's surface skimming tube

(Credit: Hanna Sistek)

Wheeler's sewage water goes through two barrels. In the first one, all the feces is collected and is broken down by bacteria. After passing another barrel, the residual water flows into a low-pressure-dose septic tank, which is buried in the ground and never needs to be emptied. Most of the water evaporates from the tank, Wheeler said.

The cost of WISY's rainwater collection system depends on the size of the tank, but it can range from $4,000 to $10,000 or more, plus labor. Filters cost around $300, a pump $500 to $800, and the UV light sterilization $1,200 to $2,000. The tank cost around $1,000.

Maintaining the system costs about $250 a year for new UV bulbs and filter cartridges, Wheeler said.

There is money to saved here: the fee to hook up a new house to the community water grid can be as much, or more, as buying a rain harvesting system. In California, for example, it costs $4,000 to $20,000 to get connected to the grid, according to Jim English, client services manager at Black and Veatch, an engineering firm that conducts water-rate studies. The monthly fees differ between water agencies and range between about $12 and $70, but are generally $25 to $35, or $300 to $420 annually.

To get drinking quality, the water is run through the two blue filters and finally through the UV light sterilizer.

(Credit: Hanna Sistek)

Wheeler's company is not the only one in this space. Stark Environmental, a small Columbia, Pa.-based company, is also importing German rainwater filter solutions from a manufacturer called 3P Technik. Stark Environmental's solutions are similar to WISY's, but the filters are made out of polyethylene rather than stainless steel. The price tag of a 3P Technik 1,700-gallon filter system excluding a UV light sterilizer, is in the range of $5,000 to $7,000.

Rainwater collection may get a boost from new storm water guidelines mandated by the U.S. Environment Protection Agency. The so-called MS4 program (Municipal Separate Storm Sewage System) addresses the earth disturbance caused by construction projects. When a new warehouse is built, for example, the amount of soil able to absorb large water masses in the area decreases. In order to diminish the erosion and transfer of sediment that heavy rainfall may cause, MS4 guidelines require municipalities to arrange systems for dealing with the water.

The man behind Stark Environmental, Michael Stark, noted that lately municipalities' focus has changed from simply getting rid of the water to reusing it. With climate change and increasing water shortages, rainwater is an excellent source for irrigation, toilet flushing, and clothes washing, he said. In the case of irrigation, it is even preferable to chlorinated tap water.

"The chlorine kills the bacteria. But in soil there is both good and bad bacteria, and to kill the good bacteria will not help in landscaping," said Stark. Both he and Wheeler believe it is a waste of energy to treat all water up to drinking standards.

"Compare it to how people are hooked on bottled water. How many of them would buy bottled water in the store, just to flush it down the toilet?" Stark asked.

The U.S. is not the only country where rainwater harvesting is heading toward a renaissance. Indian farmers, for instance in the northern state of Punjab, used to be good at rainwater harvesting until they were given free pumps and electricity by populist politicians. Now, with the ground water level sinking--thereby increasing the levels of arsenic in the water--and temperatures rising, non-governmental organizaitons like SIDA, the Swedish International Development Agency, are running programs to encourage farmers to resume their old water collecting habits.

Joe Wheeler on top of his rainwater collection tank

(Credit: Hanna Sistek)

Recent posts from Green Tech
GM: Chevy Volt still on track
Panasonic to acquire Sanyo Electric
Clean-tech investors take cue from biotech
Made in China: A plug-in hybrid for the masses
White House to provide loans to auto giants
Factory for Chevy Volt engine on hold
Battery exec: Europe ahead of U.S. on electric cars
U.S. companies team up to make electric car batteries
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 2 comments
by zenrainman June 23, 2008 12:33 AM PDT
Great work and thanks in particular for the photographs.
As part of the International Rainwater Catchment Systems Association ( www.ircsa.org) we have been advocating the wise use of rainwater and over a 100 countries have documented the use. That it also picks up in the USA is wonderful . Please keep up the good work and thanks once again for the article.
Reply to this comment
by norfunk June 23, 2008 7:21 AM PDT
Has there been a study into the effects of removing this water from city ecosystems? I don?t want to be all doom and gloom but wide scale use in a city environment could be disingenuous to the underlying greenness of the technology. For instance a lot of London?s water comes from boor holes which are sorely strained as it is to provide drinking water, any affect on the amount of water reaching these deposits could be bad news.
Although in other respects most city run off goes straight into the cities sewers and directly into the rivers. As such this method of water purification could be the answer to a myriad of flooding problems.

Who knows, it would be great to find out.
Reply to this comment

In the news now

Chip gear woes signal more trouble ahead

An "unprecedented" downturn leads one gear maker to cut 10 percent of its workforce--the latest bad news from a key part of the tech industry.

The rise of the Netbook

year in review As consumers clamped down on expenses, it appeared a prescient move that PC makers began touting the smaller, cheaper machines.

About Green Tech

Innovation in energy and environmental technologies is long overdue, in business and at home. Green-tech guru Martin LaMonica and other CNET writers serve up fresh clean-tech news and commentary.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Green Tech topics


Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right